Beer Pong Forums: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal

Forum
The WSOBP IV™
Rules Debates
Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal

Author	Message
Mywicky Joined: 09.17.2008 Age: 24 Total Games: 13 W/L %: 69.23 Avg CD: 2.00 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 22nd 2008, 10:44 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal First of CFK alternated shots with 4 cups left which was amazing feat. But my concerns come in on the 2nd game when fat kid knocks down the last cup. to put IWC into redemption, The guy without cut offs drains it for 2 cups left then cut offs makes it for one cup left but then proceeds to take the last shot when he should have alternated to his partner to make the last cup for an overtime chance. Maybe their is some second game rule I am not aware of that allows the redeeming team to choose who's shooting. If anyone who has seen the championship game part 2 from last year want to let me in on this.
Ecastro715 Joined: 11.18.2008 Age: 25 Total Games: 37 W/L %: 75.68 Avg CD: 1.27 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 22nd 2008, 10:51 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal It was forgotten at the time. The dude that hit the first cup of their 3 cup rebuttle should've had to take the last shot. No one spoke up about it, though I'm sure some people were confused on the rule as Dub was grabbing his crotch to shoot. Haha. It came up in another topic that the ruling was misunderstood or forgotten at the time. I had the same problem at a barfinder tourney in Brea. (Is this Ben or Justin?) I let Juergen shoot the first shot in rebuttle and thought I could take the next 2 because of watching Dub take the last 2 shots. I was wrong
Mywicky Joined: 09.17.2008 Age: 24 Total Games: 13 W/L %: 69.23 Avg CD: 2.00 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 22nd 2008, 10:56 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal "Ecastro715" It was forgotten at the time. The dude that hit the first cup of their 3 cup rebuttle should've had to take the last shot. No one spoke up about it, though I'm sure some people were confused on the rule as Dub was grabbing his crotch to shoot. Haha. It came up in another topic that the ruling was misunderstood or forgotten at the time. I had the same problem at a barfinder tourney in Brea. (Is this Ben or Justin?) I let Juergen shoot the first shot in rebuttle and thought I could take the next 2 because of watching Dub take the last 2 shots. I was wrong Justin, Yah so if he made that shot it could have changed things quite a bit but if that isnt enforced in a game of that magnitude then wut the hell is the point, im sure they would have made him re shoot if someone had noticed but with that many people watching that shouldnt happen. When are u heading to vegas i think im gonna fly straight vegas from wisconsin but my damm car is in the long term parking in san diego for a smooth 16 a day.
Ecastro715 Joined: 11.18.2008 Age: 25 Total Games: 37 W/L %: 75.68 Avg CD: 1.27 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 22nd 2008, 11:04 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal I'm heading out on the 31st. You've got my number. Call me whenever you get there and we'll get some tables up and beers down.
skinny Joined: 01.01.1991 Age: 31 Total Games: 1 W/L %: 100 Avg CD: 1.00 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 22nd 2008, 11:06 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal The rules were a little bit ambiguous on this point last year. We have clarified the rules this year, and if the game were to played this year, IWC's shooting progression would be legal. From the official rules, section V-K-A-1: Either player may take the first shot, and the ball is rolled back until a player misses. At this time, players MUST alternate throwers in the event of multiple hits-one player may NOT take all the redemption shots. The only exception to this rule occurs when there are three cups remaining when redemption begins. In this case, the first two shots must be alternated (i.e., the player who shoots first cannot shoot second), but the final shot may be taken by either player. Last edited on Dec 22nd 2008, 11:15 pm
Mywicky Joined: 09.17.2008 Age: 24 Total Games: 13 W/L %: 69.23 Avg CD: 2.00 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 22nd 2008, 11:15 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal "skinny" The rules were a little bit ambiguous on this point last year. We have clarified the rules this year, and if the game were to played this year, IWC's shooting progression was legal. From the official rules, section V-K-A-1: Either player may take the first shot, and the ball is rolled back until a player misses. At this time, players MUST alternate throwers in the event of multiple hits-one player may NOT take all the redemption shots. The only exception to this rule occurs when there are three cups remaining when redemption begins. In this case, the first two shots must be alternated (i.e., the player who shoots first cannot shoot second), but the final shot may be taken by either player. thats good to know thanks for clearing things up.
dub Joined: 01.01.1991 Age: 81 Total Games: 125 W/L %: 65.6 Avg CD: 1.09 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 23rd 2008, 11:03 am Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal We certainly didn't do that on purpose. Shit, I would have preferred we did it properly because we weren't sure who should take the shot. It would eliminate the nerve-wracking decision of who should shoot because there's no argument about it. Who knows...maybe Mike would have made the shot. I think at the very least, the last game should be heavily officiated. I know my partner and I were pretty trashed, so it's tough to remember what we should and shouldn't be doing. Either way, leave us alone. We've had enough nightmares about the finals. haha. Last edited on Dec 23rd 2008, 11:22 am
Mywicky Joined: 09.17.2008 Age: 24 Total Games: 13 W/L %: 69.23 Avg CD: 2.00 Full Stats	Posted: Dec 23rd 2008, 01:06 pm Post subject: Alternate Shot, Finals Last Year Ordeal "dub" We certainly didn't do that on purpose. Shit, I would have preferred we did it properly because we weren't sure who should take the shot. It would eliminate the nerve-wracking decision of who should shoot because there's no argument about it. Who knows...maybe Mike would have made the shot. I think at the very least, the last game should be heavily officiated. I know my partner and I were pretty trashed, so it's tough to remember what we should and shouldn't be doing. Either way, leave us alone. We've had enough nightmares about the finals. haha. Yah the boose n trash talking dosnt really make or an easy clear n focused mind thats why this game is so great no big deal. I read down some older posts and seen other people had noticed as well, so I just thought it was some freak thing no one noticed hah no big deal, who wouldnt have wanted to switch partners alternate at that point in time. good luck see you guys on day three.